Free form template

Interview evaluation form. Every interviewer scores the same five criteria.

The interviewer fills it in right after the interview: the candidate, the stage, five criteria from communication to motivation, strengths, concerns and a recommendation from strong hire to strong no hire. Each criterion comes with a line on what to look for. Copy the form, adjust the criteria to the role and send the link to your interview panel.

Use this template

Free plan: 100 responses a month and up to 50 surveys, no credit card.

The template’s real survey on a phone.

  • 14 ready questionsAbout 4 min on a phone.
  • Yours to changeQuestions, answers and logic.
  • A ready reportA chart for every closed question.
  • Export on every planCSV, Excel and SPSS.

After a day of interviews, impressions blur and the loudest voice wins the debrief. A short scorecard filled in right after each interview keeps every interviewer’s view on record, on the same criteria.

The 14 questions of this interview evaluation form.

In the order the interviewer meets them. Swap the criteria for what your role needs and keep the six answers the same for each.

The interview

  1. Candidate's name

    Open answer Required

    Why ask it. Ties the form to the candidate. Sort the export by this column to see every interviewer’s view of one person.

  2. Position

    Open answer Required

    Why ask it. Keeps candidates for different openings apart when one form serves several roles.

  3. Interviewer's name

    Open answer Required

    Why ask it. Shows who wrote each evaluation, so the recruiter knows whom to ask about a score.

  4. Interview date

    Date Required

    Why ask it. Puts the evaluations of a long hiring round in order.

  5. Interview stage

    Single choice Required

    • Screening call
    • First interview
    • Technical or skills interview
    • Final interview

    Why ask it. Tells a screening call from a final interview, so you can follow a candidate round by round. Rename the stages to match your process.

Five criteria

  1. Communication

    Single choice Required Explains ideas clearly, listens and answers the question asked.

    • Poor
    • Below expectations
    • Meets expectations
    • Above expectations
    • Excellent
    • Not assessed in this interview

    Why ask it. Each criterion has the same six answers and a line on what to look for, so two interviewers rate the same thing. Not assessed in this interview keeps a short screening call from forcing a guess.

  2. Skills and experience for the role

    Single choice Required The knowledge, tools and experience the position needs, shown with real examples.

    • Poor
    • Below expectations
    • Meets expectations
    • Above expectations
    • Excellent
    • Not assessed in this interview

    Why ask it. The core of the job. The description asks for real examples, so the score reflects what the candidate showed, not what the resume claims.

  3. Problem solving

    Single choice Required Breaks a problem down, explains the reasoning and reaches a workable answer.

    • Poor
    • Below expectations
    • Meets expectations
    • Above expectations
    • Excellent
    • Not assessed in this interview

    Why ask it. How the candidate reasons through a problem. A case question or a task taken from the job gives this criterion something concrete to rate.

  4. Culture add

    Single choice Required What the candidate would bring to the team: new ideas, ways of working, values that match ours.

    • Poor
    • Below expectations
    • Meets expectations
    • Above expectations
    • Excellent
    • Not assessed in this interview

    Why ask it. Asks what the person would bring to the team, not whether they resemble it. That keeps the criterion about work and values.

  5. Motivation for the role

    Single choice Required Interest in this role and company, for reasons that match what the job offers.

    • Poor
    • Below expectations
    • Meets expectations
    • Above expectations
    • Excellent
    • Not assessed in this interview

    Why ask it. Whether the candidate wants this job for reasons the job can meet. A mismatch here is worth raising before an offer.

The verdict

  1. What are the candidate's main strengths?

    Open answer Required

    Why ask it. Required, so every evaluation names what the candidate does well. The hiring team reads it next to the scores.

  2. Any concerns or gaps to check in the next round?

    Open answer

    Why ask it. What to probe next. Pass it on to the next interviewer so they don’t start from scratch.

  3. Your recommendation

    Single choice Required

    • Strong hire
    • Hire
    • Not sure
    • No hire
    • Strong no hire

    Why ask it. The interviewer’s verdict on five steps with Not sure in the middle. The chart shows at a glance whether the panel agrees.

  4. Notes for the hiring team

    Open answer Next steps, questions for the next interviewer, availability or salary expectations. Keep it about the job: leave out personal details such as age, family, health or origin.

    Why ask it. Room for next steps and handover. The hint reminds interviewers to keep their notes about the job.

Use this template

How to set up interview scorecards from this template.

  1. 1

    Copy the form

    Click “Use this template” and create a free account or log in. The form is copied to your account with all 14 questions. The copy waits in your survey list as a draft.

  2. 2

    Fit the criteria to the role

    Rename the five criteria and their descriptions, or add one for a skill the role can’t do without. The template comes with its own design; on Basic and higher you can change its colors, fonts and background in the survey’s design settings.

  3. 3

    Send it to the interview panel

    Share the link with everyone who interviews, in the calendar invite or the team chat. Each interviewer sends one form per candidate, right after the interview. The link is for interviewers, not for candidates.

  4. 4

    Compare the evaluations

    Every evaluation arrives as a separate response. Export them to Excel, CSV or SPSS on any plan and sort by candidate, or filter by the candidate’s name on Basic and higher plans.

How to compare interview evaluations.

One candidate, every interviewer

On Basic and higher, filter the responses by the candidate’s name to read all their evaluations together; on any plan, sort the export by name. Where one interviewer says Excellent and another Below expectations, ask both what they saw before you decide.

Criteria across the round

The chart for each criterion shows how the candidates of a round spread from Poor to Excellent. A criterion that keeps getting Not assessed in this interview is one your interviews don’t cover yet.

The recommendation

Hire or Strong hire on every form makes an easy call. A mix of Hire and No hire is the candidate to discuss in the debrief, with the strengths and concerns side by side.

How to keep interview scoring fair.

  1. Send it right away

    Ask interviewers to send the form within the hour, before they talk to each other. Independent scores tell you more than a view agreed in the hallway.

  2. Score what the job needs

    Keep the criteria to what the role requires. The notes question reminds interviewers to leave out age, family, health and origin.

  3. Split the criteria between rounds

    Agree beforehand which interview covers which criterion. The screening call marks the rest Not assessed in this interview.

  4. Read the words, not only the scores

    Two Meets expectations can mean different things. The strengths and concerns explain each score.

More interview evaluation questions you can add.

Not in the template. Add any of them in the builder in a few clicks.

Role-specific criteria

  • Result of the technical test or work sample
  • Leadership and people management
  • Customer focus

Practical details

  • When can the candidate start?
  • Notice period at the current job
  • Work arrangement the candidate prefers: on-site, hybrid or remote

For the next round

  • Which criterion should the next interviewer focus on?
  • Should the candidate meet the team?
  • Is a reference check needed?

Questions about this template

What should an interview evaluation form include?

The candidate, the position, the interviewer and the date, then a rating for each criterion the role needs, the candidate’s strengths, open concerns and a recommendation. This template asks all of it in fourteen questions with five criteria: communication, skills and experience, problem solving, culture add and motivation.

Can several interviewers evaluate the same candidate?

Yes. Send the same link to every interviewer. Each one sends a separate form, and the candidate’s name ties them together. SurveyNinja does not merge them into one scorecard: read them side by side with a filter on Basic and higher plans, or in the export on any plan.

Is this an applicant tracking system?

No. It is a form for interview feedback, with no candidate pipeline and no interview scheduling. Keep it next to the tools you already use and put the link where your interviewers will see it.

Which questions should interviewers avoid?

Anything not about the job, such as age, family plans, health, religion or national origin. The form asks none of them, and the notes question reminds interviewers to leave such details out. Rules on what employers may ask differ by country, so check yours.

Can I change the criteria and the scale?

Yes. Rename the criteria, rewrite their descriptions, delete one or add your own in the builder. Keep the same six answers for every criterion, so the scores compare.

Score your next interview round on the same criteria.

Copy the form, fit the criteria to the role and send the link to the interview panel.